ING Direct Increases Savings Rate To 4.5% APY, But There Are Still Better Options Available
By Jeremy Vohwinkle with 7 Comments
ING Direct announced today it was increasing the savings account rate from 4.40% to 4.50%. While this is is a fairly good rate on cash it is far from the best option for stashing away some money. ING was leading the pack for a while by providing one of the highest savings rates but that trend has since passed. You can generally find comparable rates at many other banks, some rates are even a bit better.
Personally I have never been much of a fan of opening a separate savings account with a company like ING or Emigrant. I have enough accounts as it is; checking, savings, brokerage, vanguard, etc. I don’t need to make my life any harder by opening yet another account. That is why I wrote last month about another option to these savings accounts that can not only simplify your life but yield higher returns as well.
If you do any sort of investing I’m guessing you have either a brokerage account through one of the investment firms or you have an account with a company like Vanguard. In either case you have cash options available to you without the need to open a new account and worry about liquidity issues. For example if you primarily invest in Vanguard funds you can earn a 5.09% yield on cash. You put money into this fund just like you would when buying a mutual fund, so if you already have an account with them it is easy to move some money into it.
The second option is through any basic brokerage account. Since these money markets trade like a mutual fund you likely have the option in your account to invest in nearly any of the available money market funds available. For example you can get 4.89% with the JPMorgan Prime fund or over 5% with a Fidelity Money Market fund. This is how I handle my cash position in both my standard brokerage and IRA accounts. It allows it to earn pretty good interest while sitting idle, yet it is available to me almost immediately for making a new investment purchase. Most of the third-party savings accounts have at minimum a 2-3 business day time frame for money to move from that account to your linked bank account. By holding a money market within your existing investment account you can reduce that time to same day or next day settlement.
There are a few minor drawbacks though, but they are generally not a major concern for most people. One is that since these are similar to mutual funds in how they operate, they may have minimum investment limits unlike accounts like those at ING. Some are as low as $1,000 so like I said, that probably isn’t a huge concern. The second is that of FDIC. Since they are not issued by a bank they do not fall under the FDIC like a traditional savings product, but again that is not likely to be a major concern. Finally, these rates can change more frequently than those of a savings account. In a stagnant interest rate environment this will not really make much of a difference. In a rising rate environment this can be to your advantage as the yield can change daily allowing you to take advantage of the constantly increasing rate. Just the opposite though, in a decreasing rate environment you are not locked in at a set rate so your yield can begin to decline along with interest rates.
So if you have any sort of investment account already, before opening a new account be sure to take a moment to see what other options are available to you. Not only may you be able to simplify your account holdings but you may be able to receive a higher interest rate as well.
Related: Brokerage Money Market Funds – A Great Cash Option
Don't Miss: Scottrade Review - $7 Trades and 75% Off Wall Street Journal Subscription and Get 3 Free Credit Scores and Hot Credit Card Deals
Related posts:
- FNBO Direct Savings Account Review – High-Yield Savings
- Sallie Mae Online Savings Account Offers Best Rate and 10% Upromise Bonus Match
- Poll: With significant interest rate cuts recently, what are your plans for emergency funds or other savings?
- Different Ways to Save Money – From Savings Accounts to Savings Bonds
- Does Your 401(k) Stink? You May Have Better Plan Options Available To You
Filed Under: Investing
About the Author: Jeremy Vohwinkle is a Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor® and spent a few years working as a financial planner. Today, he helps people make the most of their money by writing about personal finance here and About.com. Jeremy is also Coach at Adaptu and a regular contributor for other publications such as Intuit, and American Express. Be sure to follow Jeremy on Twitter or
Google+.
Mike, you're right and many of the brokerage firms do have those as options as well and are certainly a great option. Thanks for adding that info!
How about the online brokerage firms who are now offering the high percentage online savings accounts. I have a brokerage account with Etrade, and they offer a 5.05% complete savings account, with minimal fees (non if you truly use it as savings). I have a stock trading account, Roth IRA, and savings account with that nice yield all in one place - without the hassle of the money market fund! Thanks and great blog! Come visit my site sometime...
No, it is certainly not a global solution especially if you are simply creating a savings account for an emergency fund or vacation fund or something. I'm generally speaking to people who simply have a cash portion of their overall investments with no specific goal attributed to the money other than to be a cash holding.
And you're right, if someone is just starting out saving it can take a while to reach the minimum, so for those types it may not be the best option to start with. Once you reach the minimum purchase though you can add additional money to it in as low as $25 increments and you can set up your automatic savings just as with any account from there.
See even though INGDirect has a lower rate compared to Emigrant, the quality of customer service is much different. INGDirect has some of the best in the market which has always made me a loyal customer of theirs. Another thing is INGDirect offers there cheaper mortgage options, equity lines, and my favorite their Mutual Funds. You need an Orange account to open the mutual fund. I think ING is much better overall than Emigrant. I've had both accounts but closed the Emigrant Direct because of HORRIBLE customer service and their website is crap.
You consider a $1,000 minimum "not a major concern for most people"?
The MEDIAN annual household income is around $46K. If we assume that monthly gross income is then $3833, and someone commits to saving 5 percent of that, it will take them five months to pull together that minimum. Obviously, for the tens of millions of households below that threshold, it will take even longer. I'd much rather they started with a no-or-low-minimum account because it means they'll be more likely TO start in the first place.
I agree that people with current brokerage accounts may well find this of interest, but I don't think it's as global a solution as you imply here.
Receive free email updates and get my free Invest Like a Pro eBook.
Over the past few years, the ING Groupe has come under considerable scrutiny for a series of questionable business and investment practices. Check out the facts at www.can-you-trust-ing.com
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like