One of the frequent mistakes I see when working with clients is that they don’t gauge their personal performance with the proper benchmark. I have people who have an intermediate portfolio with 50% bonds upset because they are lagging the S&P 500 by a couple percent, while others are invested heavily in international stocks, yet compare their performance to a domestic small-cap index. It can be confusing with so many different benchmarks, and the likelihood of your portfolio not quite matching up exactly with some of them. But, if you aren’t comparing the numbers to the right benchmark, they are worthless.
Determine Your Asset Allocation First
Before you can even consider picking a benchmark, you need to actually understand what you’re really invested in. Unless you just own one index fund, you probably have a relatively complex mix of large and small-cap, international and domestic companies, bonds, cash, or maybe even other specialty investments. Once you know the breakdown of your portfolio, you can then begin to look for the appropriate benchmark to measure it against.
The best way to do this is to use the free Portfolio Manager tool at Morningstar. Registration is free, and this login will allow you to access many other free tools available throughout the site. With portfolio manager you can track and analyze your portfolio, using unique Morningstar features such as Portfolio X-Ray, Interpreter, and Stock Intersection.
When you create a portfolio, you can track what investments you have and the number of shares owned. Here is a quick snapshot of what you’d see after entering your holdings:
Use the X-Ray Tool For More Detail
One of the most handy tools is the X-Ray tool. This will show you a detailed breakdown of your portfolio from asset class, credit quality and maturity, market sector, and even compare holdings to the S&P 500. This is where you really begin to understand what your portfolio is made out of. In this example, we can see that this portfolio is heavy on large-cap stocks across all three areas from value to growth, and contains around 14% of holdings in bonds and cash. Clearly, this portfolio isn’t 100% equity, and the allocation of holdings does not match the S&P 500 exactly, so that would not be an appropriate benchmark.
Compare Results to an Appropriate Benchmark
Now that you understand how your portfolio is structured, you can find a benchmark that is more closely aligned with your true holdings. Morningstar provides yet another tool within the portfolio tracker to provide a quick estimate as to how well your portfolio is doing with the Performance tab. Once you select that tab, you can see how your returns matched up against various benchmarks of your choice. Obviously, this doesn’t take into account multiple purchases over time through dollar cost averaging or any withdrawals, but it shows you what that particular portfolio would have done over the specified time frame.
Let’s look at two different examples to see how they differ. We’ll first compare the trailing 12 month period against the S&P 500, which is the default benchmark:
Vs. S&P 500
Clearly, your portfolio is not performing as well as the S&P 500, and it shouldn’t. Remember, you are holding various investments, some of which have more of a growth component, not to mention close to 14% in fixed income. So the question shouldn’t be concerned with the under performance, but whether or not that performance is appropriate for your investment mix.
Since this portfolio contains almost entirely large-cap stocks across value through growth, a closer benchmark at least for the equities portion would probably be the Morningstar Large-Cap Core benchmark:
Vs. Large Core
As you can see, the performance gap against this benchmark is a bit closer than to the S&P. Again, this isn’t a completely accurate representation since the actual portfolio does hold bonds, but the YTD, 1-Year and 3-Year returns are generally insignificant, often under 0.5%. This is actually quite good for essentially an 85/15 mix of stocks and bonds.
There will never be a perfect way to measure performance once your portfolio begins to get complex, but comparing it to the most appropriate benchmark will give you a much better idea of how it is actually doing. You could be beating the S&P by 10%, but if you are invested in a few specific sector funds, that doesn’t mean anything. Maybe you’re beating the S&P, but you might be in some of the worst performing funds of that particular sector and not doing as well as you should. Just the same, you might have 50% of your portfolio in bonds, yet only lag the S&P by a couple points. That would be fantastic if you could do that well with such a high percentage of fixed income in your portfolio.
So, it all comes down to what you’re comparing your returns to, and before you make any drastic changes to your investments based on performance, make sure you are comparing to the right benchmark. You may think that the 5% return you’re earning every year stinks, but if you examine your portfolio closely, it may be doing exactly what it should be based on how it is constructed.
Author: Jeremy Vohwinkle
My name is Jeremy Vohwinkle, and I’ve spent a number of years working in the finance industry providing financial advice to regular investors and those participating in employer-sponsored retirement plans.